Wyoming Gov.-elect Eric Barlow (R) is facing criticism from conservatives after selecting Cheyenne attorney Walter Eggers, a longtime Democrat and major donor to Democratic candidates and organizations, as his nominee for state attorney general.

Barlow announced the nomination Nov. 10, marking one of his first major personnel decisions since winning the governor's race. The appointment has raised concerns among conservative voters who expected the incoming Republican administration to place strong conservative figures in positions responsible for defending the state's laws.

Federal Election Commission records show Eggers contributed $18,735 to the Wyoming Democratic Party between 2004 and 2020, along with donations to several prominent Democratic politicians and organizations. His contributions include $2,300 to former President Barack Obama, $1,800 to the Democratic National Committee, $1,250 to Hillary Clinton, $1,000 to Joe Biden and $250 to Kamala Harris in 2024.

Eggers has confirmed that he is a lifelong Democrat. His donation history also shows a pattern of financial support for the state Democratic Party, with contributions recorded during multiple election cycles.

The choice is particularly significant because Wyoming's attorney general serves as the state's chief legal officer and represents the government in major legal disputes. The next attorney general will be responsible for defending state laws, including Wyoming's abortion restrictions and its What Is a Woman Act, both of which are facing legal challenges.

Barlow campaigned as a conservative Republican, telling voters, “My record shows I am a conservative Republican.” However, his record has drawn criticism from conservative activists. The Wyoming Liberty Index gave him a lifetime score of 43%, including 33% for the 2023-2024 period.

The Wyoming Freedom Caucus also previously argued that Barlow was not conservative enough to serve as governor, adding to concerns among grassroots Republicans about the direction of his incoming administration.

Eggers' nomination now moves to the Wyoming Senate, which must confirm the appointment when lawmakers convene in January. Senators will ultimately decide whether to approve a nominee whose political contributions have overwhelmingly supported the Democratic Party.

For a state that consistently votes Republican and has some of the country's strongest conservative political traditions, Barlow's decision is likely to face scrutiny from lawmakers and voters who expected his administration to reflect the priorities he emphasized during his campaign.