The Iowa State Board of Education will consider Wednesday whether to renew Choice Charter School, the state’s statewide virtual charter school. Board staff recommend a one-year term with conditions.

The renewal packet posted Monday recommends the board approve Choice’s renewal “with conditions.” The first condition sets the contract term at “July 1, 2027 to June 30, 2028.” Iowa law allows renewals of up to five years, according to the same packet. Staff recommend Hamburg Charter High School, also up for renewal Wednesday, for “a full five-year term” without conditions.

The board meets at 9 a.m. Central time in the Grimes State Office Building in Des Moines, and the public may attend in person or remotely, according to a Department of Education news release dated Nov. 16. The Choice item is set for about 10:40 a.m. on the meeting agenda, which calls all times approximate.

What the board would require

Under the staff recommendation, Choice would have to reach “an overall performance score of 60% or better as measured by the Iowa Charter School Performance Framework” by its renewal date. The state’s website shows Choice Charter received a grade of 23.84% for FY25.

The school would also have to “submit audits for FY23, FY24, and FY25 that meet Iowa’s statutory requirements by June 30, 2027,” using an Iowa-licensed auditor, and send each audit to the Auditor of State and the department.

A third condition asks for a training plan for the school’s governing board on separating the school’s chief executive from board “membership screening, recruitment, and appointment.” Earlier, the State Board had told Choice to “discontinue administration-directed board selection practices.”

Choice disputes the department’s findings. According to the packet, “The school refutes the findings of the board selection process and asserts full compliance with state laws, contract terms, and governing board bylaws.” It also “asserts there were no repeated findings and no multiple findings from 2023, 2024 and 2025.”

The school’s numbers

Choice serves grades 7 through 12 on a statewide online platform and opened in 2022-23, according to the department’s Charter Schools Legislative Report. It enrolled 281 students on the Oct. 1, 2025, count.

For 2024-25, the report lists Choice’s average daily attendance at 71.7%, its four-year graduation rate at 38.3% and its dropout rate at 34.7%. Statewide figures in the same table are 93.9% attendance, an 88.8% four-year graduation rate and a 1.6% dropout rate. The report’s highlights section separately says the school “reported a 9% student chronic absenteeism rate.”

In its renewal application, Choice says it serves “students with severe chronic absenteeism, school avoidance concerns, complex mental and physical health challenges, and those previously at risk of dropping out,” and that “traditional standardized testing measures fail to accurately represent their capabilities, growth, or academic progress.” The school reports that 90% of its students are on track to graduate, citing Panorama data, and that it doubled its platform’s capacity to 200 concurrent users.

Virtual Schools are not District Schools

How to judge virtual schools that enroll students who struggled elsewhere is an open research question. A July 2026 Educational Freedom Institute report, Virtual Schools Reconsidered, examines the limits of test-score comparisons for those schools. EFI keeps a searchable Research Database of school choice studies.

Families choose education options outside their zoned district school for many reasons, as noted above. Lawmakers and regulators score schools based on a narrow set of parameters that often fail to account for the benefits that make each school attractive to parents and students. In the case of Choice Charter, which is representative of so many other virtual charter schools around the country, families have enrolled for specific individual reasons.

Regulators shouldn’t threaten to shut down a school that is meeting a need that, in its absence, would force students back into a system that ignores or marginalizes them.