More than one-third of Americans who voted for President Donald Trump in 2024 did not cast a ballot in the November midterm elections, according to a new analysis from polling firm J.L. Partners. The findings suggest that Republican losses were driven primarily by supporters staying home rather than abandoning the party for Democratic candidates.

The analysis, titled Sitting Out the Surf: How Turnout, Not Swing, Built the Blue Wave, found that 35% of Trump's 2024 voters did not participate in the Nov. 3 elections. By comparison, 22% of voters who supported Kamala Harris in 2024 also stayed home. Just 8% of Trump's previous supporters voted for Democrats in the midterms.

According to J.L. Partners, reduced Republican turnout accounted for 10 percentage points of the 15-point shift toward Democrats since 2024, while voters switching parties accounted for the remaining five points. The firm concluded that Republicans would have lost control of both the House and Senate even if no Trump supporters had crossed over to vote Democratic.

The turnout decline was especially pronounced among several groups that have traditionally been important to the Republican coalition. Among Trump's 2024 supporters, 46% of those without college degrees did not vote in 2026. The same was true of 44% of voters over age 65 and 39% of rural voters.

"The GOP should not throw the MAGA baby out with the bathwater just yet," J.L. Partners founding director James Johnson said. He argued that Republicans could remain competitive in 2028 if they find a way to bring their previous supporters back to the polls.

"Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House," Johnson said.

The findings also add to the debate over why Republicans suffered such significant losses. President Trump has argued that the party struggled because he was not personally on the ballot, while Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has pointed to frustration with congressional Republicans and their failure to advance campaign promises.

"A lot of our voters who stayed home, they stayed home because they were frustrated with the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate," DeSantis told Fox News. He added that voters had been promised major accomplishments that Republican lawmakers did not deliver.

The survey also identified potential challenges for Democrats as the parties begin looking toward the 2028 presidential election. Nearly half of Democratic voters, 48%, said their midterm vote was primarily an expression of opposition to Trump rather than support for the Democratic Party's platform. Only 30% of registered voters said Democrats have a presidential candidate ready for 2028, according to J.L. Partners.

Economic concerns were another major factor in the election. The cost of living and the broader economy were the two leading issues across demographic groups, with approximately one-third of voters identifying one of them as a top concern. No other issue was selected by more than 9% of respondents. Johnson suggested that the war in Iran may have contributed to frustration over rising prices, particularly gasoline.

The J.L. Partners analysis was based on an Election Day survey of 1,000 registered voters and more than 30,000 interviews conducted during the campaign. The firm reported a margin of error of 3.1 percentage points for its registered-voter sample and 3.3 points among 2026 voters.

The results suggest that Republican efforts to recover before 2028 may depend heavily on addressing why a substantial portion of Trump's previous supporters did not participate in the midterms, rather than focusing exclusively on voters who switched to the Democratic Party.