A federal appeals court has upheld Hamtramck, Michigan’s policy prohibiting Pride flags and other private-group flags from being flown on city-owned flagpoles, ruling that the city may reserve the displays exclusively for government speech.

On August 21, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed a lower court ruling in favor of the city. The decision upheld a September 2025 judgment by U.S. District Judge David M. Lawson dismissing a constitutional challenge brought by two former members of Hamtramck’s Human Relations Commission. The appellate panel concluded that even if the flagpoles had previously served as a forum for private expression, the city had the authority to close that forum and take control of the displays.

The policy, Resolution 2023-82, was unanimously adopted by the Hamtramck City Council in June 2023. It prohibits flags representing religious, ethnic, racial, political or sexual-orientation groups from being flown on city property. The resolution permits the American, Michigan and Hamtramck flags, the Prisoner of War/Missing in Action flag, and flags of nations representing the city’s international character. Residents and businesses remain free to display Pride flags and other flags on private property.

The dispute followed a change in the city’s political leadership. In November 2021, voters elected the first all-Muslim city council in the United States, along with Muslim Mayor Amer Ghalib, a Yemeni immigrant. Hamtramck, a Detroit-area city of approximately 28,000 residents, has large Yemeni and Bangladeshi communities and is widely recognized as the nation’s first Muslim-majority city. The new administration sought to change the city’s approach to displaying flags on public property.

For roughly a decade, Hamtramck’s Human Relations Commission had overseen 18 city-owned flagpoles along Joseph Campau Avenue. Under an unwritten policy, residents could request flags, most commonly those representing countries with which they had personal or family ties. In 2021, the commission received a request to fly a Pride flag. Commission chairman Russ Gordon ordered one, which was eventually raised in 2022. The new administration asked Gordon to remove it, but he refused, and the flag remained on display through the end of that year.

When the council adopted Resolution 2023-82, members cited the goal of treating residents equally and avoiding requests from what the resolution described as “radical or racist groups.” Council members also expressed concern that displaying a Pride flag conflicted with the religious beliefs of many residents. Gordon and fellow commission member Cathy Stackpoole later raised a Pride flag in defiance of the new policy. City officials had it removed, and the council subsequently removed both members from the commission and stripped the commission of its authority over the flagpoles.

Gordon and Stackpoole sued the city, alleging violations of their First Amendment free-speech rights, the Establishment Clause and the Equal Protection Clause. Judge Lawson ruled in favor of the city, finding that the resolution had closed the flagpoles to private expression and reserved them for government speech. The Sixth Circuit agreed, explaining that the policy did not allow the public to participate in selecting which flags appeared on city property.

The appeals court relied in part on the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in Shurtleff v. City of Boston, which addressed government-owned flagpoles and the distinction between private expression and government speech. The Sixth Circuit concluded that Hamtramck could change the purpose of its flagpoles and reserve them for messages selected by the city. It also rejected the plaintiffs’ Establishment Clause challenge, finding insufficient evidence that the resolution’s neutral language was a pretext for advancing religion. The court did not decide the equal-protection claim on its merits, ruling instead that the plaintiffs had forfeited it by failing to adequately develop the argument.

The judgment was affirmed by all three judges, although Judge Amul Thapar wrote separately, concurring in the judgment while disagreeing with part of the majority’s reasoning. Hamtramck City Attorney Odey Meroueh described the outcome as a vindication of the council’s approach, arguing that the city had simply reserved its own flagpoles for its own speech while leaving private expression protected.

The plaintiffs have indicated they intend to seek rehearing, challenging the appellate court’s decision. The ruling leaves Resolution 2023-82 in effect and reinforces the authority of local governments to reserve publicly owned displays for government speech, even when those displays had previously been used for private expression.