Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is pursuing a broader trade relationship with China after reaching another agreement with Chinese dictator Xi Jinping on Tuesday. The two leaders announced additional tariff reductions covering several industries, as Ottawa seeks to diversify its economic partnerships beyond the United States.

Under the agreement, Beijing will reduce tariffs on approximately $280 million worth of Canadian pork and seafood imports. Canada, in turn, agreed to lower tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminum, along with certain other products for which Canadian supplies are considered insufficient or unsustainable.

The latest concessions build on a series of trade decisions that have drawn scrutiny from Canadian critics. Following an earlier meeting with Xi in Beijing in January, Carney described China as a “more predictable” trading partner than the United States. His government subsequently moved away from Washington's trade approach by reducing Canadian tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles, prompting Beijing to ease restrictions on Canadian agricultural and seafood exports.

Carney is now looking to extend that cooperation into additional industries. His office said the discussions with Xi included opportunities to expand cooperation in both conventional and clean energy, as well as a higher import quota for Chinese electric vehicles. The prospect of greater access for Chinese automakers has raised concerns about the future of Canada's domestic auto industry and its longstanding integration with American manufacturers.

Those concerns have become more significant as Carney threatens to pursue alternative partnerships if negotiations with President Donald Trump fail to produce an acceptable trade arrangement. On Monday, he identified China, Japan and Europe as potential partners for Canada's auto industry, raising the possibility of a major shift away from its traditional reliance on the American market.

Following Tuesday's meeting, Carney defended the new direction, arguing that closer relations with Beijing would create economic opportunities for Canadian businesses and workers.

“Canada and China have recalibrated our relationship to the benefit of citizens in both countries,” Carney said. He added that the agreements had opened export opportunities for Canadian farmers, ranchers and fishing industries while making it easier for citizens of both countries to travel, study and conduct business.

Xi also praised the relationship, emphasizing the importance of cooperation despite political differences. “We must respect each other, pursue equality and mutual benefit and seek common ground while setting aside differences,” the Chinese leader said.

However, Canadian commentators and former officials have questioned whether the economic benefits justify closer dependence on Beijing. Tasha Kheiriddin of the National Post argued that China cannot realistically replace the United States as Canada's primary trading partner, pointing to differences in consumer spending power and concerns over the Chinese government's human rights record.

Kheiriddin noted that Chinese consumers spend substantially less than American households, limiting the country's ability to absorb the volume of Canadian exports currently sold to the United States. She also warned that China's economic ambitions extend beyond offering inexpensive products, citing concerns over ethnic repression and forced labor.

Michael Kovrig, a former Canadian diplomat who was detained by China for nearly three years before his release in 2021, offered a similar warning in an interview with CBC News. Kovrig said the relationship between the countries should not be treated as though previous tensions have disappeared.

“There are definitely some potential benefits. The challenge is to make sure that the benefits don’t come with bigger and more problematic downsides,” Kovrig said.

He also criticized the absence of national security, human rights and detained Canadian citizens from the public discussion surrounding the latest agreement. Kovrig argued that those issues should receive attention alongside trade access, warning that Beijing has repeatedly used economic pressure to influence the decisions of smaller countries.

The closer relationship with Xi has also raised concerns about the impact on Canada's partnership with Washington. Trump trade adviser Peter Navarro criticized Carney's approach Monday, calling it “offensive in the extreme” for the Canadian prime minister to “play China off the United States” in pursuit of better trade terms.

Kovrig likewise urged Carney to recognize the importance of maintaining relations with Washington, saying, “You have to put Washington first. I know that’s not a popular idea in Canada right now.”

Carney and Xi met in Shenzhen ahead of this week's Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, scheduled for Wednesday and Thursday. Trump is also expected to attend, although Canadian officials have indicated they do not anticipate a meeting between the American president and Carney during the gathering.