New Mexico's pioneering universal childcare program is facing heightened examination as costs exceed projections and oversight concerns mount.

A year after the state became the first in the nation to offer free childcare to all families regardless of income, officials are proposing co-pays for higher-earning households. The Early Childhood Education and Care Department scheduled a public hearing for December 3 on rules that would require payments ranging from $15 to $99 monthly for one child, or up to $148.50 for multiple children, for families earning at least six times the federal poverty level.

The proposal stems from inflation triggers in the enabling law. It would affect roughly 10 percent of participants. State lawmakers have voiced worries that the program is already running about $50 million over its nearly $600 million operating budget.

Republican state Sen. Steve Lanier, who previously sued unsuccessfully to halt the expansion, described the approach as adding wealthier families to an already strained system. Legislative analysts have flagged risks to long-term funding, which relies heavily on oil and gas revenues.

Whistleblower lawsuits have added to the pressure. Former department CFO Carmel Pacheco-Aragon alleged retaliation after raising an $83 million shortfall for fiscal year 2026 and questioning fund transfers without proper legislative approval. A second suit from former budget director Kimberly Gonzales claimed a larger $258 million hole and retaliation for similar disclosures.

Safety issues at specific providers have drawn separate attention. State records released this week showed repeated violations at New Mexico Early Learning Academy locations, including hygiene problems, improper food storage, and staff conduct issues. The Tijeras site had its license suspended after inspectors found no running water and children in prolonged distress. A 1-year-old died there in September after choking on food, prompting a wrongful death lawsuit.

Enrollment has reached more than 50,000 children, with demand outpacing available slots in many areas. Supporters note life-changing benefits for working parents, while critics argue the program's rapid rollout bypassed traditional fiscal safeguards and risks crowding out targeted aid for lower-income families.

Incoming Gov.-elect Deb Haaland has pledged to sustain the initiative as an economic driver. The department maintains that adjustments will keep the program viable without major disruptions.