California prosecutors from dozens of counties and victims' advocates sued Gov. Gavin Newsom this week to block his plan to commute every death sentence in the state to life without parole.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed the petition Monday at the California Supreme Court on behalf of district attorneys representing about 30 counties and multiple victims' family members. The suit argues Newsom violated state law by failing to notify prosecutors and victims' families before issuing the mass commutations announced earlier this month.
Newsom's action targets all 548 inmates on California's death row. He requested Supreme Court approval for 382 cases involving multiple felony convictions, as required by the state constitution. The governor claimed the remaining commutations did not trigger the same review because they involved single convictions.
Plaintiffs contend the governor exceeded his authority with a blanket approach that skipped mandatory individualized reviews and notifications. They described the move as an abuse of power that disregarded victims' rights under California law.
Newsom announced the commutations around November 5 as one of his final acts before leaving office at the end of the year. He cited moral objections to the death penalty, stating that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with state values.
The lawsuit seeks to halt implementation and require proper procedures. It distinguishes Newsom's commutation authority from broader presidential pardon powers, noting California statutes impose notification requirements when altering sentences.
Some district attorneys have supported the commutations, but the majority of those involved in the suit oppose the mass action. The Supreme Court has begun reviewing the petition and requested a response from Newsom's office.
If successful, the commutations would represent the largest single clearing of a death row in modern U.S. history. California has not carried out an execution in over two decades.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.